Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum | Rum Reviewer Expert Rum Reviews

papa's pilar

If you know anything about the man who inspired this rum and for whom it is named, you won’t be surprised to find that Papa’s Pilar Dark rum is a complex and interesting bottle if rum that delivers a robust, yet unexpected rum sipping experience. Earnest Hemingway traveled the world and wrote about mankind’s strife, the rum named for him does the same.

If you come to Papa’s Pilar Dark rum expecting a traditional Caribbean rum, you might be disappointed, but if you’d like to broaden your horizons and accept a new entry into the rum sipping world, pick up a bottle of Papa’s Pilar Dark and take the journey.

Fast Facts About The Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum

Of all the information available about a specific type of rum, there are four main staples that differentiate them in terms of both quality and flavor. The type of rum, the price point/quality of the rum, its country of origin, and the ABV (alcohol by volume). The fast facts for Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum below.

Rum Type

Dark Rum

Price Point

More Expensive

Origin Country

United States


43.0% ABV

The Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum Notes

Tough like the writer, Papa’s Pilar Dark punches you right square in the nose with a powerful burn smelling of leather, oak, and coffee beans.

Tasting Notes

Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum : Packaging and Product

papa's pilar

Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum : Our Personal Take

We love a new rum and a new experience. Old favorites are a comfort but new friends are always welcome and Papa’s Pilar Dark rum is one of our new favorites that will be a regular addition to the rum shelf. Not a rum we will reach for on a nightly schedule, but certainly one that deserves a mention when friends come over or you’re in the mood to sample something unusual.

Papa’s Pilar Dark tends to sip more like a sweet whiskey than a traditional rum, a drink perfectly suited for sharing among sipping friends. The stories behind the bottle and the name can be shared together as you contemplate the flavors of this rum. Papa’s Pilar Dark can’t be recommended as a “standard” sipping rum, but as a rum sipping experience can’t be recommended enough!

Rum Reviewer’s Final Thoughts

Every well-stocked bar should have a few bottles that you pull out for unusual occasions. Papa’s Pilar Dark rum fits the bill for this need. The rum itself is unusual, and in a world of similarities, the unusual often deserves to be noticed. A good sipping rum for the novelty, Papa’s Pilar Dark rum is worth the purchase.

Other Rums from United States

Country of origin, especially the location of the ingredients utilized in the manufacture of a rum, has a strong impact on the resulting taste, scent, and value of a rum. While Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum may not be the best option for your personal taste, there are other rum options from United States. Below are some other great rum choices.

Other Dark Rum in the More Expensive Category

Sometimes, maybe a specific rum is not the perfect choice for your personal taste and needs, however, you know that you’re in the right space. When that is the case, typically the same type of rum around the same price point will provide a similar, yet slightly different mouthfeel and experience. Below are some alternatives to The Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum that is Dark Rums at a More Expensive price point.

Recommended Drinks To Make With The Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum

The best way to enjoy a high-quality rum such as The Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum is to utilize it in a nice drink. Below are four great drink recipes that will be enhanced by utilizing The Papa’s Pilar Dark Rum in place of any low-quality rum you may consider.